Harald Bohr correspondence
The destiny of Harald Bohr's correspondence
The few letters in the Harald
Bohr Papers in Copenhagen is a very tiny fraction of the large amount of letters
to and from
Bohr which once existed. According to Bohr's son, Ole Bohr, Bohr
kept the letters he received and organized them well until
April 1940 where he destroyed most of them shortly after the German
invasion of Denmark. He did that because he was anxious that the Germans
should seize on his correspondence and misuse its information about
German mathematicians, whom Bohr had helped to leave Germany.
According to Asger Aaboe (Yale University), who has had contact with the
surviving relatives, the left over of Bohr's collection of correspondence
(among other things his correspondence with Godfrey H.
Hardy) was kept by Bohr's wife Ulla Bohr for many years, but destroyed
by her in the 1970s. There is probably no more correspondence
kept by the surviving relatives, at least not any scientific
correspondence, and the only part of Bohr's own collection of
correspondence which has survived are the letters in the
Harald Bohr Papers and some family correspondence (mainly
letters to and from his brother Niels) kept in the
Family correspondence at the Niels Bohr
Archive.
Hence, the major part of the correspondence listed below is located in other
collections. The correspondents are divided in two groups. The first
group, which is given alphabetical in a table with links to more
details, consists
of correspondents where more than one letter to or from Bohr has been
conserved. The second group consists of all the minor
correspondents where only one letter to or from Bohr has been conserved.
List of Harald Bohr's major correspondents
The table is an alphabetical list of correspondents who has exchanged letters
with Bohr and where more than 1 letter is conserved.
Below the table is given a short description of the correspondence with each
correspondent from the table above or a link to a place
where such a description may be found, and the place where the
correspondence is located including a link to the address of the
location.
Correspondent |
Letters from Bohr |
Letters to Bohr |
Language |
|
Years |
# |
Years |
# |
|
Adler, Hanne |
|
|
1911 |
2 |
Danish |
Bang, Thøger |
1939-47 |
6 |
1940 |
1 |
Danish |
Blumenthal, Otto |
1928 |
1 |
1928 |
1 |
German |
Bochner, Salomon C. |
|
|
1925-27 |
15 |
German |
Bohr, Niels |
1909-50 |
58 |
1906-50 |
69 |
Danish |
Brun, Viggo |
1924-50 |
19 |
|
|
Danish |
Carleman, Torsten |
1922-43 |
8 |
|
|
Danish |
Courant, Richard |
1930-52 |
66 |
1930-52 |
104 |
German, English |
Ehrenfest, Paul |
1928-30 |
9 |
1928-33 |
4 |
German |
Flexner, Abraham |
1933 |
5 |
1933 |
9 |
English |
Friis, Aage |
1933-37 |
4 |
1933 |
2 |
Danish |
Hardy, Godfrey H. |
|
|
1910-16 |
7 |
English |
Hasse, Helmuth |
1934 |
1 |
1934 |
3 |
German |
Hecke, Erich |
1920-37 |
7 |
|
|
German |
Heckscher, Eli |
1927-50 |
13 |
|
|
Danish |
Höffding, Harald |
1920-29 |
3 |
|
|
Danish |
Jessen, Børge |
1928-50 |
137 |
1928-49 |
42 |
Danish |
Landau, Edmund |
1910-13 |
8 |
1911-34 |
18 |
German |
Mittag-Leffler, Magnus Gustaf |
1910-26 |
25 |
|
|
Danish |
Pál, Julius Franz |
1927-32 |
29 |
|
|
Danish |
Oppenheimer, Robert |
1947-48 |
2 |
1947 |
1 |
English |
Oseen, Carl Wilhelm |
1912 |
2 |
|
|
Danish |
Pólya, Georg |
1914-26 |
9 |
|
|
German |
Strömgren, Eli |
1922-28 |
3 |
1928 |
4 |
Danish, Swedish |
Szegö, Gabor |
1926-38 |
11 |
|
|
German |
Veblen, Oswald |
1922-51 |
36 |
1924-51 |
25 |
English |
Weyl, Hermann |
1926-30 |
2 |
|
|
German |
Wiener, Norbert |
1925-35 |
8 |
|
|
English |
- Hanne Adler's letters to Harald Bohr
- Adler was one of Bohr's aunts. The letters are two postcard
to Harald and Niels Bohr during their visit to Göttingen in the summer
of 1911. They are located in
the Family Correspondence, Niels Bohr Papers, Niels
Bohr Archive, Copenhagen.
- The correspondence between Thøger
Bang and Harald Bohr
- The correspondence is about proof reading of articles, Bang's
visit to Bohr's cottage (where mathematicians gathered during the
summer) and about Laurent Schwartz. The correspondence is located
in the Thøger Bang Papers possessed privately by the widow
Eva Bang, Copenhagen.
- The correspondence between Otto Blumenthal and Harald Bohr
- The letter to Blumenthal is written jointly by Bohr and Richard
Courant. The correspondence is about David Hilbert's attempt to get
rid of Luitzen E. J. Brouwer in the editorial board of the journal
Mathematische Annalen.
The location of the originals is not known. A photo copy of the
correspondence is in the file CB MA (Mathematische Annalen), the Brouwer
Archief, the Netherlands.
- Salomon C. Bochner's letters to Harald Bohr
- Bochner's letters are about the theory of almost periodic
functions and one of them contains his simplified proof of the
Weierstrass approximation theorem for almost periodic functions.
The letters are located in folder
6, box 2, Harald
Bohr Papers, The
Archive, Institute for Mathematical Sciences, University of
Copenhagen, Denmark.
- The correspondence between Harald and Niels Bohr
- The content shows the close relationship between the two
brothers and their families.
The correspondence before 1920 gives details about their mutual
help in their student years and about their early scientific
experience abroad (Harald in Göttingen, Niels in England).
The correspondence is located in the Family Correspondence,
Niels Bohr Papers, Niels
Bohr Archive, Copenhagen. A part of the correspondence from
1909-16 has been published in Niels Bohr: Collected Works,
Volume I: Early Works (1905-11), edited by L. Rosenfeld and J. Rud
Nielsen. North-Holland Publishing Company, Amsterdam 1972, pp. 495-589
- Harald Bohr's letters to Viggo Brun
- Bohr writes about his participation in a meeting in Innsbruck
(1924), displaced German mathematicians (1933-34), the Scandinavian
congresses of mathematicians in Copenhagen (1946) and Trondheim (1949),
Carl L. Siegel and Helen Braun's stay in Denmark (1947) and the
attempt to create a professorship in Norway to keep Atle Selberg
there.
The letters are located in Brevsamling 719 [Letter collection 719] at
the
University Library of Oslo, Norway.
- Harald Bohr's letters to Torsten Carleman
- Bohr writes about
The letters are located at Mathematics, Faculty of
Sciences, Lund University, Sweden.
- The correspondence between Harald Bohr and Richard Courant
- The correspondence before 1945 is in German and possessed privately
by Ernest D. Courant (New York). There is originals of Bohr's letters
and carbon copies of Courant's letters.
The major part of the content is about the attempts to help
German mathematicians,
who were displaced by the Nazis from 1933, to get positions outside
Germany. There is also information about their colleagues,
mathematical works and the contacts to publishers, especially
the Springer-Verlag.
The correspondence after 1945 is in English and
kept in the Harald Bohr Archive
Correspondence Folder, in the archival Courant file cabinets,
Courant
Institute of Mathematical Sciences,
New York (not in the library).
The content is mainly about family matters and their
mutual visits after 1945.
- The correspondence between Paul Ehrenfest and Harald Bohr
- They may be found at ESC 1, Section 5, No. 137-49 on the microfilm
of the Ehrenfest Papers, which is located at Museum
Boerhaave, Leiden, the Netherlands.
- The correspondence between Abraham Flexner and Harald Bohr
- These letters are about how to help displaced German mathematicians
to find new positions in the USA. They are located in the Members
file: Professor Harold Bohr, Historical
Studies - Social Science Library, Institute for Advanced Study, New Jersey.
- The correspondence between Harald Bohr and Aage Friis
- It is located, together with further relevant material, in
the Aage Friis Papers, the Danish National
Archives, Copenhagen.
- Godfrey H. Hardy's letters to Harald Bohr
- They are described and located in folder
8, box 2, Harald
Bohr Papers,
The
Archive, Institute for Mathematical Sciences, University of
Copenhagen.
- The correspondence between Helmut Hasse and Harald Bohr
- There is one letter from 1926 written by Hasse located at
the
library, Department of Mathematics and Computer Science, University of Southern
Denmark.
The rest of the letters are from 1934 and about Deutsche Mathematik.
Copies of them exist as enclosures to letters from Bohr to Veblen in the general
correspondence folder Bohr, Harold
1922-51, Box 3, Oswald Veblen Papers, Library
of Congress, Washington D.C., USA.
- The letters from Harald Bohr to Erich Hecke
- They were located at the the
Mathematisches Seminar, Universität
Hamburg, Germany (1996), but copies of all letters are in the
Niels Bohr Archive, Copenhagen, Denmark.
- The letters from Harald Bohr to Eli Heckscher
- They are located in signum L 67:6 (Eli Heckscher),
Department
of Manuscript, The Royal Library, Stockholm, Sweden.
- The letters from Harald Bohr to Harald Höffding
- They are located in NKS 3815-4o, the
Manuscript Department, the National
Library, Copenhagen, Denmark.
- The correspondence between Børge Jessen
and Harald Bohr
- The correspondence is located in the general correspondence folders
Harald Bohr 1928-40 and Harald Bohr 1941-, the
Børge Jessen Papers,
the
Archive, Institute for Mathematical Sciences, Copenhagen, Denmark.
- Correspondence between Edmund Landau and Harald Bohr
- They are described and located in
folder 9 and 10, box 2, Harald
Bohr Papers,
The
Archive, Institute for Mathematical Sciences, University of
Copenhagen.
- The letters from Harald Bohr to Magnus Gustaf Mittag-Leffler
- They are located in the Mittag-Leffler Papers, Institut
Mittag-Leffler, Djursholm, Sweden.
- The letters from Harald and Ulla Bohr to Julius Pál
- They are located in box 1 of the Julius
Pál papers,
The
Archive, Institute for Mathematical Sciences, University of
Copenhagen.
- The correspondence between Harald Bohr and Robert Oppenheimer
- They are located in the Members
file: Professor Harold Bohr, Historical
Studies - Social Science Library, Institute for
Advanced Study, New Jersey.
- The letters from Harald Bohr to Carl Wilhelm Oseen
- They are located in the Carl W. Oseen Papers in the library of
the Royal
Swedish Academy of Sciences, Stockholm.
- The letters from Harald Bohr to Georg Pólya
- There is one letter from 1914, which is located in the Folder 11, Box 1,
Pólya Papers,
Special Collection 337, Department
of Special Collections, The Stanford University Libraries,
Stanford. The rest of the letters from 1922-26 are located in
Briefe an der Mathematiker Georg Pólya,
Hs. 89: 60-68, Wissenschafthistorische Sammlungen,
ETH-Bibliotek, Zürich.
- Harald Bohr's correspondence with Svante Elis
Strömgren
- The letters are located at the
University Library of Lund.
- Harald Bohr's letters to Gabor Szegö
- Bohr writes about mathematics (almost periodic functions),
as editor of Mathematische Annalen, about displaced
German scholars and about family matters. One of the letters
is written by Bohr's wife Ulla.
The letters are located in Folder 20, Box 5, Szegö Papers,
Special Collection 323, Department
of Special Collections, The Stanford University Libraries,
Stanford.
- The correspondence between Harald Bohr and Oswald Veblen
- Except for two letters the correspondence is located
in the general correspondence folder Bohr, Harold
1922-51, Box 3, Oswald Veblen Papers, Library
of Congress, Washington D.C., USA. Two letters from July and October
1947 are located the Faculty file: Siegel, Carl L., Historical
Studies - Social Science Library, Institute for
Advanced Study, New Jersey.
- Harald Bohr's letters to Norbert Wiener
- Bohr writes about almost periodic functions, his plan of a book
about this subject, about Wiener's career and about displaced German
scholars. The letters are located in the Wiener Papers, Manuscript
Collection 22,
Institute Archives and Special Collections, The Libraries, MIT,
Massachusetts.
- Harald Bohr's letters to Hermann Weyl
- Bohr writes about reflection on almost periodic functions and
congratulate Weyl for getting Hilbert's professorship in Göttingen.
The letters are located in Briefe an der Mathematiker Hermann Weyl,
Hs. 90: 486-87, Wissenschafthistorische Sammlungen,
ETH-Bibliotek, Zürich.
List of minor correspondents
Below is first an alphabetical list of selected people
who have received letters from Bohr,
but where only one letter is conserved. After that there is an alphabetical
list of selected people
who have sent letters to Bohr, but where only one letter
is conserved.
List of minor receivers
- Bjerknes, Vilhelm 1945 (Danish)
- Location: Brevsamling 469B [Letter collection 469B] at
the University
Library of Oslo, Norway.
Content: Bohr thanks for a received book and describes the liberation
of Denmark in May 1945.
- Brouwer, Luitzen E. J. 1928 (German)
- Location: In the file CB BOL (Bologna Congress), the Brouwer
Archief, the Netherlands.
Content: Bohr's reaction to Brouwer's suggestion to the German
mathematicians to boycot the International Congress in Bologna 1928.
- Carathéodory, Constantin 1928 (German)
- Location: In the file CB MA (Mathematische Annalen), the Brouwer
Archief, the Netherlands.
Content: Bohr has written the letter together with Courant.
It is about the editorial problems in the journal Mathematische
Annalen.
- Drachmann, A. B. 1919 (Danish)
- Location: In the collection Utilg. 188,
the Manuscript Department, the National
Library, Copenhagen, Denmark.
- Holmgren, Israel 1944 (Danish)
- Location: Brevsamling Israel Holmgren [Collection of
letters, Israel Holmgren], Uppsala
University Library, Sweden.
- Hopf, Heinz 1949 (German)
- Location: Briefe an der Mathematiker Heinz Hopf,
Hs. 621: 269, Wissenschafthistorische Sammlungen,
ETH-Bibliotek, Zürich.
- Prytz, K. 1920 (Danish)
- Location: In the collection NKS 2752-2o
, the Manuscript Department, the National
Library, Copenhagen, Denmark.
- Rantzau 1948 (Danish)
- Location: Folder
28, box 10, Harald
Bohr Papers,
The
Archive, Institute for Mathematical Sciences, University of
Copenhagen, Denmark.
- Salomonsen, Carl J. 1917 (Danish)
- Location: In the collection NKS 2741, 2o
B. I. b. 1., the Manuscript Department, the National
Library, Copenhagen, Denmark.
- Severi 1934 (German)
- Location: A copy exists as enclosure to a letter from Bohr
to Veblen in the general correspondence folder Bohr, Harold
1922-51, Box 3, Oswald Veblen Papers, Library
of Congress, Washington D.C., USA.
List of minor senders
- Brazma 1940 (German)
- Christian X 1910 (Danish)
- Erdös, Paul 1948 (German)
- Fuglede, Bent 1948 (Danish)
- Neugebauer, Otto 1932 (German)
- Nørlund, Niels Erik 1946 (Danish)
- Paludan-Müller, K. 1950 (Danish)
- Perron, Oskar 1934 (German)
- Rademacher, Hans 1934 (German)
- Richardson, R. G. D. 1935 (English)
- Rogosinski, Werner 1936 (German)
- Sommerfeld, Arnold 1934 (German)
Last updated: 2000.06.07